Skip to main content

Why Is My Ina Garten Brownie Pudding Runny?

Ina Garten brownie pudding runny? The center should be soft, but soupy means under-beaten eggs, hot butter or a cool water bath. Here's how to fix it.

Clayton Redmon, founder of ChefittClayton RedmonCulinary Educator
Published 4 min read
Baking cooking technique — Why Is My Ina Garten Brownie Pudding Runny?

Ina Garten's brownie pudding is supposed to be runny in the middle. It bakes at 325°F for 1 hour in a water bath, and the recipe's own doneness test calls for a tester inserted 2 inches from the edge to come out about three-quarters clean, with the center still looking underdone. If the edges are set and the middle is like warm fudge sauce, you made it right. If the whole dish sloshes from edge to edge, something went wrong before it ever reached the oven.

You spoon into it at the table, and instead of a crackly top over molten pudding, you get a puddle that runs across the plate and melts the ice cream on contact. Here's why.

Soft center or actually underbaked?

Look at the edges first. A good brownie pudding has a thin, crisp top and a ring about 2 inches wide that holds its shape on a spoon, cakey near the dish and fudgy toward the center. Only the middle should flow.

If the edges are wet too, or the top never formed a crust, it's underbaked or under-structured. That's the version worth troubleshooting.

What makes it too runny

The thing that matters most:

The eggs and sugar have to be beaten until thick.

That foam is most of the structure in this dessert. There's only half a cup of flour holding up two cups of sugar and two sticks of butter, so the air you whip into the eggs is doing the work flour would do in a cake.

  1. The eggs weren't beaten long enough. The recipe calls for beating eggs and sugar on medium-high for 5 to 10 minutes. Stop at 2 and you get a thin, glossy batter that bakes into syrup. Keep going until it turns pale and thick and falls off the beater in a ribbon that sits on the surface for a few seconds.
  2. The butter went in hot. Melted butter needs to cool to roughly room temperature before you add it. Hot butter deflates the foam you just built, and pouring it in all at once does the same thing. Drizzle it slowly with the mixer on low.
  3. The flour and cocoa got overmixed. Once the dry ingredients go in, mix on low only until they disappear. Every extra turn on high knocks out air.
  4. The eggs were too small. Ina uses 4 extra-large eggs. Four large eggs are about a quarter cup short, which is less protein to set the batter. If you only have large, use 5.
  5. The dish or the water bath was off. The recipe uses a 2-quart dish, with hot water poured halfway up its sides. A smaller, deeper dish leaves a thicker center that won't set in an hour. Cold tap water in the bath steals heat for the first 15 minutes, and the pudding never catches up.
  6. Your oven runs cool. At 325°F, a 25-degree error is a big slice of the heat this dessert gets. An oven thermometer costs less than the chocolate.
  7. You served it straight from the oven. It firms up as it cools. Scooped at minute one, even a correct pudding is looser than it will be at minute 20.

Related: 4 Baking Science Rules That Fix Every Texture Fail

How to fix it, now and next time

If it's already baked and soupy, put it back in a fresh hot water bath at 325°F and check every 10 minutes with a tester 2 inches from the edge. Then let it rest 20 to 30 minutes before serving. That rescues an underbaked one. It won't rescue a batter that was deflated, because there's no air left to set.

Next time, bring the eggs to room temperature, beat the full time, cool the butter, and use boiling water from a kettle for the bath. If you double the recipe, use two 2-quart dishes rather than one deep one. The bake time is built around that depth.

One food-safety note: the soft center may not reach the 160°F the USDA recommends for egg dishes. If you're serving anyone pregnant, very young, elderly or immunocompromised, use pasteurized eggs.

Related: Why Is My Pumpkin Pie Watery? (And How to Fix It)

I set a timer for 8 minutes on the eggs and don't touch the butter until it's cool enough to hold my finger in. Then I let the pudding sit 20 minutes while we clear dinner.

Share this article

More from Chefitt

Keep reading.

The Chefitt Newsletter

Cook with more confidence.

Weekly chef techniques delivered to your inbox. The why behind every method, translated for the home kitchen.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.